Home › Insights › Biogas vs natural gas gensets

Biogas vs natural gas generator sets: what actually changes in the configuration

Buyers often assume the choice is "the same genset, different fuel line". It is not. The engine platform is usually shared, but the gas train, derating, treatment and control logic change — and those changes decide whether your plant runs for 8,000 hours a year or fights derated output and fouled oil.

The short version

A natural gas genset is specified around a stable, clean, high-methane fuel at fairly consistent pressure. A biogas genset is specified around a variable, wet, contaminated fuel at low and fluctuating pressure. Same block, different fight. Everything below follows from that single difference.

1. Methane content drives derating, not the nameplate

Biogas from a digester typically carries roughly 55–65% methane with the balance mostly CO₂; landfill gas can sit lower, and it moves as the landfill ages. Natural gas is usually in the 85–98% methane range depending on the grid or field. Lower methane means a lower energy content per cubic metre, so the same engine makes less power on the same volumetric flow.

Two consequences worth writing into your specification:

2. Gas treatment shifts from "filter" to "process"

On natural gas, the train between the pipeline and the mixer is mostly a regulator, a filter and a shut-off valve train. On biogas, it becomes a small process plant:

ContaminantWhat it doesTypical response
Hydrogen sulphide (H₂S)Acid formation, accelerated oil degradation, corrosion of bearings and linersDesulphurisation (biological or dry media), plus an oil specification matched to the actual H₂S level
MoistureFree water in the gas train, erratic combustion, condensation in the intakeCooling and knock-out, gas drying, heating of the gas line where climate demands it
Siloxanes (landfill, some waste streams)Deposits on valves, pistons and turbochargers, glass-like ash in the combustion chamberCarbon filters or scrubbers sized on a gas analysis, not on a guess
Particulates and foam carry-overPlugged filters and mixers, unstable air/fuel ratioCoalescing filtration, drip traps, revised filter service intervals

This is where a biogas project's cost is decided. A "biogas-ready" sticker without a treatment scope matched to your gas analysis is the most expensive sentence in the quotation. We publish our position on this in gas treatment before the engine.

3. Gas pressure: the most common late-stage surprise

Digester and landfill sites often deliver gas at a pressure that is low and — more importantly — variable. Engines want a stable supply pressure into the gas mixer. The project therefore usually needs a gas booster or at least a properly sized regulator station with buffer volume.

Practical rule: lock the required inlet pressure at the mixer and the guaranteed pressure and flow at the site boundary as two separate numbers in the contract. If only one number is agreed, that argument lands at commissioning — after the container has shipped.

4. Configuration differences that show up on site

5. What to send your supplier (one page, saves weeks)

With that page, a supplier can commit to an output figure, a gas consumption figure and a guarantee — which is what your bank and your EPC actually need.

FAQ

Can the same generator set run on both biogas and natural gas?

Often yes in principle, but the delivered configuration should be specified for the fuel you will run most of the time. A dual-fuel or changeover configuration needs the gas train, control maps and derating defined for both cases — and the commissioning should be done on the primary fuel.

Do I need a gas booster for biogas?

Frequently yes. Digester and landfill gas pressure is often below what the mixer needs and varies with gas production. Confirm the required pressure at the mixer with your supplier before sizing treatment and boosters.

Why are two supposedly equal quotations 30% apart?

Almost always treatment scope, derating assumptions and control hardware. Compare the two offers line by line on gas quality basis, treatment equipment, output at your gas composition, and what is excluded.

Send us your gas analysis — get the configuration, not a brochure

Tell us the gas composition, flow, pressure and load profile. We reply with a configured proposal: output at your gas, consumption basis and guarantee values.

Request a Quotation